In some installations, yes, particularly when signals are strong, but this should not be interpreted to mean that omnidirectional antennas are universally better for attic installations.
An attic can create a complicated RF environment. Signals may pass through roofing materials, reflect from framing, ductwork, wiring, neighboring buildings, and other objects, then arrive at the antenna from directions that do not exactly correspond with the geographic direction of the broadcast tower. Channel Master's pointing guidance specifically identifies this effect as one reason indoor and attic antenna aiming can be less predictable than outdoor aiming.
An omnidirectional antenna such as the Channel Master Omni+ 50 (CM-3011HD) is designed to receive over a broad 360 degree horizontal area rather than concentrating its reception primarily toward one direction.
In a strong signal area, that broader reception pattern can sometimes be advantageous inside an attic because a usable signal may reach the antenna through a direct path, reflected path, or combination of paths without requiring precise directional aiming.
However, the same characteristic can also become a disadvantage.
If strong copies of the same signal arrive from several directions with different delays, the antenna can deliver multiple versions of that signal to the tuner. This is multipath. Modern digital tuners are designed to tolerate a certain amount of multipath, but sufficiently difficult multipath conditions can reduce decoding margin and contribute to pixelation, dropouts, or complete loss of reception. ATSC receiver guidelines specifically include multipath performance because of its importance to terrestrial digital reception.
A directional antenna can sometimes improve this situation by favoring one signal path and rejecting reflected signals arriving from other directions.
Therefore, an omnidirectional attic antenna can work very well where signals are strong and the indoor RF environment is favorable, while a directional antenna may perform better where additional gain or rejection of unwanted reflected signals is necessary.
Testing the antenna at several locations and orientations is often the most reliable way to determine the best attic configuration.